Elvira's Spooky Season Feud

It's one sided but the beef is real
avatar
Posted on Oct 13, 2026 by
Ed Anderson
History,   Entertainment,   Celebrities,   Money
  in Zone  Pieces of History
6 mins read 
Elvira and Vampira in a cemetery, scary
Image by Edward Anderson

In 1940, Malia Nurmi wanted to pursue a career in the entertainment industry. She decided to move to California in pursuit of her goal but found that it was tougher than she expected. Most of her gigs were canceled or worse, went nowhere. A few even cut her altogether.

She also did some modeling for designers. That money helped pay her bills, while she figured out how to make her career take off.

After deciding that nothing was happening with her film career, Nurmi made her way to New York. She appeared in a few productions and began making a name for herself.

In 1944, she was set to star opposite Mae West in the play, Catherine Was Great. But the actresses ended up in a feud. West, the star of the show, felt that Nurmi was taking too much attention from her. Producers tried to calm the tension between them.

“It’s her or me,” West said. Producers made the decision to keep their star happy and fired Nurmi.

After losing the Broadway gig, Nurmi headed back to Los Angeles. She figured that she needed to become a star in order for her to have the power that West enjoyed.

She took more modeling gigs as she auditioned for movie roles. Things did not move as fast as she would have liked. Directors thought she was beautiful but worried that she would not be able to take on the roles she wanted.

Then came a role in another Broadway show that would change her life. The show was Spooky Scandals. It would introduce her to the type of horror character that would catapult her to the level of fame that she craved.

A few of her designer friends helped her craft the look for an iconic horror character. Man Ray gave Nurmi a pair of “bat glasses” that would become an essential part of the character.

And soon the world would know the character.

. . .

Nurmi was invited to attend Lester Horton’s annual Bal Caribe Masquerade in 1953. She whipped up a costume based on the character that she was working to create.

Part of her inspiration came from the comic strip known as The Addams Family. Specifically, she liked the way the as-yet-unnamed wife looked. Nurmi decided to copy the design for her own character.

Thus, Vampira was born.

During the gala, Hunt Stromberg Jr., a producer for KABC 7, caught sight of Nurmi. He thought that she would make a great host for a series of horror movies. But he didn’t know how to contact her.

“I want to hire that woman. We need to find a way to contact her,” Stromberg said. Eventually, he was able to get her phone number from Rudy Gernreich.

One sticking point in making a deal was who owned the character of Vampira. Eventually, KABC relented and agreed to allow Nurmi to hold the rights to the character.

The Vampira Show debuted on April 30, 1954. It was a big hit for KABC right out of the gate. Vampira was everywhere. They did a lot of marketing using the character.

Then came the shock. Less than a year after it launched, the show was canceled.

ABC forced the station to cancel it because Nurmi would not give them the rights to Vampira.

Thanks for reading Pieces of History ! This post is public so feel free to share it.

. . .

ABC saw the potential in having a late-night horror movie series on air. But they wanted to be able to control the narrative surrounding Vampira. They also did not want to have to pay Nurmi for using the character.

After the cancellation, Nurmi took Vampira to a rival station in 1956. KHJ-TV was thrilled to have the rights to broadcast the show. Ratings showed that the audience still loved her.

But Nurmi made a fatal mistake. She appeared as Vampira on KABC as a favor to a friend. Her new bosses were furious and pulled the show from production.

“I own the rights to the character,” Nurmi argued.

“We have a no-compete clause in your contract,” a lawyer for the station countered.

And just like that, Vampira was gone.

Nurmi tried to keep the character alive and relevant. She put together a movie called Vampira: The Movie but it was never released. A collector now owns the only print copy known to exist.

It appeared as though Vampira would be forgotten to time and Nurmi’s career was over.

But there was one more act in store for the character.

In 1981, KHJ-TV reached out to Nurmi to ask her to bring her show back. This time, she would be an executive producer on the show and have more say over things.

Negotiations went well. They worked out a format and everything seemed to be on track for production to start. This time, it appeared as though, everyone was on the same page.

Enter Elvira.

. . .

When it came time to sign contracts, Nurmi showed up and was shocked to see Cassandra Peterson there. She hadn’t signed off on hiring anyone and was supposed to be consulted about every decision.

“They eventually called me in to sign a contract and she was there. They had hired her without asking me.” Nurmi said to an interviewer for Bizarre Magazine.

The problem was that Nurmi hadn’t signed her contract. Executives at KHJ-TV decided that Peterson was the right woman to help carry on the tradition of Vampira. She was set to play Elvira, the daughter of Vampira.

Nurmi did not like the idea. She claimed that Peterson did not understand Vampira at all. At the meeting, she said as much. But things did not go the way she thought they would.

Executives informed her that the decision was made. Either she could get on board with it, or she could leave. Nurmi chose to leave the project. Both sides told the press that they parted because of “creative differences.”

The station moved ahead with the show. Instead of using the Vampira branding, they renamed the show Elvira’s Movie Macabre. This incensed Nurmi.

She vowed revenge. To anyone who would listen, Nurmi complained that they stole her likeness and her idea.

An attorney heard her story. He checked things out and came to the conclusion that Nurmi might have a case. But he cautioned her, it was an uphill battle.

Nurmi decided to take a chance.

A lawsuit was filed against Peterson and the station. The complaint stated that the former was using her likeness for profit and the former was allowing her to do it. Nurmi wanted money and an injunction to stop the show from going on.

“In this case, the plaintiff does not allege that the defendants actually tried to copy exactly the Vampira character in creating Elvira. By the plain terms of the complaint, the defendants are alleged to have created a new character that resembled the Vampira character but which used a different name and employed a different actress in the lead role. The Court finds that because these allegations do not amount to the claim that the plaintiff’s actual features were used by the defendants for commercial purposes, no common law right of publicity or privacy action can be maintained. Thus, the plaintiff’s fourth and fifth claims are dismissed,” The judge said in his ruling.

Nurmi lost the lawsuit but was determined to keep the feud alive.

. . .

Bitter after losing the lawsuit, Nurmi vowed that Peterson would not find success. She complained and insulted the other woman every chance she got.

Hecklers and thugs began showing up at Elvira events. They would make lewd comments for the most part. But at one signing, they actually pushed Peterson.

Nurmi gloated that she was the one who sent them.

When it looked like a production company was about to sign Peterson to a deal to turn the Elvira character into an animated show, Nurmi fumed. She began to look for anything that would scuttle the deal.

Eventually, she found nude photographs of Peterson that were taken when she was younger. The pictures were sent to the production company and the deal was called off.

Peterson was confused. She hadn’t done anything to Nurmi, so why was the other woman after her?

“I’d like her to be friendly with me. I don’t know why she has such hostility toward me,” Peterson said to an interviewer.

A truce between the women would never come. Nurmi died on January 10, 2008, in her garage apartment in Hollywood.

Peterson came out as a lesbian in her 2021 memoir, Yours Cruelly, Elvira. She continues to portray the character that made her famous.

History
Entertainment
Celebrities
Money
Comment
React
Play
Menu
avatar
Written by
6 Followers
Following 9
Ed is a true crime and history writer. He is known as the publisher of Crimebeat.